Chocolate Hazelnut Gelato: Bringing the Magic of Italy Late Nights Home

What’s your definition of late night? Mine has been forever altered by late night strolls in Italian piazzas. Night after night, we would emerge from a long dinner out with the kids to be greeted anew by the magic of late night piazzas. Around 9:30PM, long after the official bedtime in our house in the US, Italian piazzas come alive for young and old. As generations of adults socialize, kids play hide and seek, ride their bikes, and run wild and free. Pure magic. All around the local gelateria.

Chocolate Hazelnut GelatoWhen I think back to our trip in Tuscany this August, it is the taste of creamy gelato on my tongue and the sound of the kids’ laughter, echoing across the darkened piazza that fills my memory.

Sophie GelatoI can’t bring little Italian children and their games back to my life in Chicago, but gelato can be a reality. Steve’s parents surprised him with a Kitchenmaid ice cream and gelato maker for his birthday upon our return from Italy. The machine is a dream, a definite step up from the frozen canister type of ice cream makers. It whips up a batch of gelato in 45 minutes, and is then ready to whip up a different batch right away. The Kitchenaid gelato and ice cream maker is around $299 – about three times a regular freeze canister ice cream maker, but well worth it. There is even a keep cool function, so that if you get called away from the ice cream maker, you won’t return home to a so very sad melted puddle.

Screen Shot 2015-09-08 at 1.06.26 PMGelato making has been our new passion, ever since unpacking our bags from Italy. We’ve made creamy strawberry gelato (FRAGOLA!) to recreate our favorite flavor. But we keep returning over and over again to our greatest creation yet: chocolate hazelnut gelato. It’s an adaptation of the recipe in the kitchenmaid booklet, and pure decadence in a cup.

Last GelatoWe have been having so much fun with our gelato creations, I couldn’t wait to share our favorite recipe with you.

Gelato is actually a slightly less guilty pleasure than ice cream, because it contains less heavy cream, and thus less butterfat. There are also no eggs in most gelato flavors. Gelato’s creamier texture comes from the fact that it is denser and thus has less air, or overrun. Here’s an interesting NPR piece on the differences between gelato and ice cream. The fact that this chocolate hazelnut recipe has a full jar of Nutella in it still makes this dessert far from guilt free, but a decadence that’s worth every calorie.

Chocolate Hazelnut Gelato: Bringing the Magic of Italy Home
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
Cuisine: Italian
Serves: 8-10 small servings
  • 1¾ cups of heavy cream
  • 2¼ cups of 2% milk (divided into 1½ cups and ¾ cups)
  • ½ cup of granulated sugar
  • ½ cup of cocoa powder
  • 2 tablespoons of corn starch
  • 1 pinch of kosher salt
  • 1 13oz jar of Nutella
  1. Combine 1½ cups of milk and the heavy cream in a medium saucepan. Over medium heat, bring to a simmer. Keep an eye on it so that it doesn't boil over!
  2. In a separate mixing bowl, combine the rest of the milk (3/4 cups) with the corn starch, sugar, salt, and cocoa powder. Stir until it is a homogenized and loose paste.
  3. Add the cocoa mixture to the simmering milk and heavy cream. Spoon in the jar of Nutella. Stirring fairly constantly, leave the mixture cooking over medium heat until it starts to boil and thickens so that it coats the back of a spoon.
  4. Turn the heat off. Pour into a bowl and refrigerate for about 2 hours.
  5. Get your ice cream maker out. If you have one, put the gelato paddle on. If not, use the paddle you have. Set the machine for 45 minutes. The gelato will still be soft when it's done, but should have a thick consistency.
  6. Enjoy it soft, like a cold pudding, or refrigerate it a couple of hours to have the more traditional gelato texture.
  7. Then pour into the ice cre





Leave a reply